Normally someone who has 711 points in 712 career games, would be considered a star player. Normally.
However, when it comes to the career of Charlie Simmer this adage does not seem to apply. You see, he spent an amazing career in the NHL, amassing almost a point per game pace for his career, played on one of the most productive lines in NHL history, and garnered accolades every year for his play.
To this day, Simmer holds a record in the NHL. He has the highest scoring percentage of any player who has played 700 or more games.
Charlie Simmer was more than just a good player, he was a great player who somehow got lost in the shuffle. If you mention his name today, some have heard of him, some have not, but he will forever be remembered for his contributions while playing on the great “Triple Crown Line” of the Los Angeles Kings.
Marcel Dionne, Dave Taylor and Simmer dominated the league for many years, with Simmer being a huge part of that.
Charles Robert Simmer was born March 20 1954 in Terrace Bay, Ontario, Canada. As a junior player he dominated in his one season with the Sault Ste. Marie Greyhounds. He had 99 points in that one season and it was enough for scouts to take notice. He would soon be living the dream.
In the 1974 NHL entry draft Simmer would be chosen 39th overall by the California Golden Seals.
Simmer soon went to work with the Seals farm club the Salt Lake Golden Eagles of the old CHL. He was a dominant player in the minors, having 41 points in 47 games his first season. He would also get a taste of NHL action that year playing in 35 games with the Seals, and earning a respectable 21 points for a rookie.
The following season Simmer would appeared in 21 NHL games but would only earn two points (1 goal and 1 assist), yet he was tearing it up in the minors with Salt Lake earning 39 points in 42 games. There was becoming a wide discrepancy between his NHL and CHL numbers, and it was disturbing to the organization who had had high hopes for Simmer. Not to mention the team was in dire straits of losing the team altogether.
Unfortunately, with the team in financial disarray they would be relocated in the 1976-77 season to Cleveland and were renamed the Barons. Simmer went along with them, but still had their affiliate in Salt Lake City, so Simmer really didn’t have far to move.
Once again Simmer found himself buried in the minors, for the most part. He played 24 games for Cleveland but only scored two goals. It was becoming more and more apparent that Charlie Simmer was a much better performer in the minor leagues than he was in the pros. He recorded an amazing 62 points in only 51 games for the Golden Eagles and was named an all star that year.
Things were looking up for Chrlie Simmer, but not for the Cleveland franchise as it was losing more money than its predecessor in Oakland. Simmer felt his prospects of making it in this organization were slim so in the summer of 1977 he signed as a free agent with the Los Angeles Kings.
Though he spent his first season with the organizations minor league affiliate, the Springfield Indians, he felt that this was a better place to seek promotion. The Kings were treating him well, and said they had high hopes for him. They were not kidding.
That season Simmer saw NHL ice for three games with LA, but they were fairly uneventful. On the flip side, 83 points in 77 games in Springfield was impressive, so much so in fact that the Kings wanted Simmer on the big club the following season. He would begin 1978-79 back in Springfield due to an overload at the forward position for the Kings.
Again in the minors, Simmer registered 36 points in 39 games, and was flying with the Indians. Halfway through that season, Simmer was promoted to the Kings. It would be the last time he would ever play a game in the minors.
Simmer recorded 48 points in 37 NHL games and was placed on a line with Taylor and future Hall of Famer Marcel Dionne, simply on a hunch. That hunch paid off in spades. The Triple Crown Line, as they became dubbed, was one of the most productive and feared lines of that era.
The following season, 1979-80, would be Simmers first complete season in the NHL and what a season it was. Simmer scored 56 goals, added 45 assists for a grand total of 101 points. His minor league talent had finally caught up to his NHL talent and the line was giving other teams fits. They seemed to score at will, and Charlie Simmer had become a key component of that freewheeling style.
One of the Kings greatest accomplishment came during the 1981-82 season. The Edmonton Oilers were beginning their dominance in the league and lead by young stars like Wayne Gretzky and Mark Messier were running roughshod over anyone in their path. During this particular playoff year, the Kings put up a great fight and managed to defeat the heavily favored Oilers, knocking them out of the playoffs. One of the games in that series even ended with a final score of 10-8! Thus, proving that the Kings could compete with the best.
Simmer had a downer of a regular season that year as injuries hampered his play. He had finished 1980-81 with another 56 goal performance, and even scored goals in 13 consecutive games that season, which still holds as a modern era record. Yet, 1981-82 would prove to be the way of things to come.
Simmer would be dogged by injuries his whole career and this was something he was going to have to get used to. However, after the defeat of the Oilers during the playoffs, which became known as the “Miracle on Manchester” ( referencing the name of the street the Kings arena was on) Simmer was very productive, recording 11 points in 10 playoff contests, showing that he was always up for the big game.
Charlie Simmer would play two more productive years with the Kings recording 80 and 92 points respectively, and was an integral piece of the Kings puzzle for all of the years he was part of the organization.
But the team failed to make the playoffs even with all their first line talent, and management felt that Simmer was beginning to slow down, especially with his injuries, despite his numbers.
At the start of the 1984-85 season Simmer looked unhappy. His numbers declined in the pre-season and once the regular season hit, he was not playing as consistently as he once had. The Kings even moved him off the Triple Crown Line to see if that made a difference, but the Kings and Simmer could see that change was imminent. After only five games in 1984-85, Charlie Simmer was dealt to the Boston Bruins for their first round pick in that years upcoming draft. The Kings ended up selecting a player named Dan Gratton who never had more than a cup of coffee in the NHL, meanwhile Simmer would go on to produce for the Bruins.
In his first season with Boston, Simmer played in 63 games and recorded exactly the same amount of points. He also had four points in five playoff games that year, the first time he had competed in the post season since 1981-82. Though still battling the injury bug, Simmer seemed much happier and more composed. He was amazed at the talent the young Bruins had, especially a young defenseman by the name of Ray Bourque, who he was more than happy to be on the ice with in key situations.
In 1985-86 Simmer would earn 60 points in 55 games, but it was evident the injuries were catching up with him. He would play one more season in Boston before the Bruins too felt he was slowing down and placed Simmer on waivers.
He was claimed by the Pittsburgh Penguins and spent his final NHL season there, but this time as a role player. For the first time in his life he was a healthy scratch and his 28 points in 50 games was a far cry from the man who once scored 50 goals in 51 games.
Feeling the strain of the NHL game and the amount of games they play, Simmer decided to leave the NHL and headed off to Germany for the 1988-89 season. He still possessed the passion to play the game, just not the amount of games required for the professional style of the NHL.
Eintracht Frankfurt allowed him to still make a living off the game he loved, yet play at a much more suitable pace for his tired, battered body. He was also able to do this in relative obscurity as not many folks in Germany new who Charlie Simmer was.
He played one season for Frankfurt and put up impressive numbers of 51 points in 36 games. The following season he retired having accomplished amazing things in an eventful career.
He attempted new things starting in 1989 and was loving his life away from the game. However, as always, the itch needed to be scratched. In 1990-91 Simmer came out of retirement to become a player coach for the San Diego Gulls of the IHL. The season was not a productive one for either himself or the team as they missed the playoffs.
Simmer would only suit up for one game the following year and became a full time coach the rest of that season. However, the coaches life was not something that greeted Simmer with success.
After this he retired for good, being the last player from the California/Cleveland franchise to play professional hockey.
Simmer was never fortunate enough to win a Stanley Cup in his career, or even make it past the second round of the playoffs. He competed in numerous all star games, was named the winner of the Bill Masterton trophy in 1986, and was even married to Terri Welles, a former Playboy Playmate at one time, but none of this seemed to matter.
Charlie Simmer had lived his dream by playing in the NHL. He had accomplished what he set out to do so many years previous.
Today he spends his days as a part time colour analyst for the Calgary Flames, and is loving every minute of it.
In the end, it’s not the accolades that will keep Charlie Simmer in our memories. It’s his perserverence through the early years in California/Cleveland where no one belived in him. It’s the desire he showed in battling back from injuries. It’s the passion he played with every single season, no matter the league.
Charlie Simmer would finish his pro career one point shy of being a point per game player. That in itself is an accomplishment, and one that Charlie Simmer will forever be proud of.
Still there is always the “what ifs”. What if California had had more faith in him and given him more ice time? What if he hadn’t been injured all the time? What if the LA Kings were more than a one line team?
None of these questions will ever be answered, but one thing we do,is that Charlie Simmer was an amazing player who is truly deserving of recognition, especially in Underrated Nation.